This article has been contributed by Jordan Cole, Collections Officer, Shoemakers Museum at Clarks Village, Street, Somerset. If you have any comments or suggestions relating to the article, please email me at deweymiked@aol.com, and I will forward them on to Jordan.

Jordan writes: When putting together our exhibition this summer on the different ‘paths’ shoes have taken to end up in our collection, one of the most interesting paths we identified was one that is quite literally hidden: concealed shoes.

Hidden shoes

In the late 1950s, June Swann, a curator at Northampton Museum, noticed a pattern among shoes being offered to the museum. Across the country, old shoes were turning up hidden inside buildings; built into walls, ceilings and floors. Intrigued by the number of finds, and recognising the need for a consistent way of recording them, Swann established the Concealed Shoe Index. It is still active today and now contains more than 3,000 recorded finds.

The locations of these shoes are particularly interesting. Many have been found close to potential points of entry into a building, such as above doors and windows, or inside chimneys and fireplaces. This has led researchers to suggest that they may have been deliberately hidden as protective charms, intended to keep evil spirits out, or perhaps as offerings associated with good luck or fertility. The exact reason, however, remains uncertain. We simply do not have contemporary written accounts explaining why people concealed shoes.

It is easy to dismiss the finds as rubbish, lost belongings or objects that were simply forgotten. After all, old buildings contain all sorts of things. Shoes are the most common objects, but cats, other animals and pieces of clothing have also been found. What makes concealed shoes particularly interesting is the combination of their sheer numbers and where they are found. They tend to turn up in places associated with structural alterations - under floors, in ceilings, inside walls and around fireplaces -which suggests that many were deliberately placed there rather than accidentally lost.

Testing the theory

Even so, there is still room to question the theory. There is remarkably little written evidence for the practice. We might expect some mention of concealed shoes in the historical record, particularly during the 17th century, when fears about witchcraft and supernatural forces were widespread, or in the 19th century, when folklorists were actively recording traditional beliefs and practices. Yet there is no clear contemporary account explaining why people did it.

June Swann did collect a small number of later memories of the practice. One woman told her that she had seen her father and a workman place an old, worn-out boot that did not belong to the family underneath a kitchen floor in Norfolk in around 1934–35. Accounts like this provide some evidence that deliberate concealment was taking place, but they still leave us wondering what people believed they were achieving.

There are also some intriguing historical connections. Historian Ralph Merrifield suggested that concealed shoes might be linked to the medieval story of Sir John Schorne, a 14th-century rector from North Marston, Buckinghamshire, who was said to have conjured the Devil into a boot. His shrine became a place of pilgrimage until the Reformation, and his association with boots survives in local traditions and pub names. It is tempting to see this as supporting the idea that evil could somehow be trapped or contained within a shoe. There is also a certain logic to the story: medieval shoes could be remarkably narrow and pointed, making the idea of the Devil being trapped in one slightly easier to imagine. Anyone who has ever worn an uncomfortable pair of shoes might sympathise.

The 19th century is the period in which concealed shoes are most frequently found. This could mean that the practice was particularly popular at the time, but there is another, perhaps more convincing, explanation: there are simply more surviving 19th-century buildings that have not been substantially altered since they were constructed. Earlier concealed shoes may therefore be much harder to find.

Ultimately, the biggest problem with researching concealed shoes is the lack of documentation. We know where they have been found, and we know that there are thousands of examples, but we rarely know why they were put there. Rather than giving us a definitive answer, the shoes force us to look at the wider context of the buildings, the beliefs of the people who lived in them and the traditions surrounding them. Sometimes, what a museum object cannot tell us directly is just as interesting as what it can.

Concealed shoes found in Marlow

This pair of brown leather Derby shoes was found concealed inside a Clarks shoe shop at 68 High Street, Marlow, during renovations in 2015. One of the shoes has been pierced, exposing its inner construction. Unfortunately, because asbestos was used in shoemaking during the period when these shoes were made, we cannot safely clear this shoe and has to remain in quarantine.

They are the most recent concealed shoes in the Shoemakers Museum collection dating to around 1922 or possibly slightly earlier. We can date them to then because there is newspaper stuffed inside the shoes from November 20th, 1922.

I had no further information than the address and that it was a Clarks shoe shop in 2015. Looking at the map today the premises has been taken over by ‘The Ivy’ but opposite is the distinctive ‘Chequers’ pub and to the left ‘The White House’ a grade 2 listed building with easy-to-spot bowed windows. The website ‘Sharing Wycombe’s Old Photographs’ or ‘SWOP’ had dozens of photos of Marlow High Street in the 1920s. Looking for the bowed windows of the White House I soon found a photo of 68 High Street or, as it was then, Milwards shoe shop. Milwards was bought out by Clarks and so many of the company papers ended up in our archives, including account books which showed that Milwards opened in Marlow in July 1923. It seems reasonable to deduce that these shoes were concealed whilst the shop was being constructed. It was noted they were found ‘inside a cavity wall’ suggesting intentional concealment, and not simply some shop stock that had been long lost. These shoes are particularly unusual because they are both lightly worn and still together as a pair. Most concealed shoes show considerably more wear.

There are a few possible explanations for this. Before the 20th century, shoes were expensive, particularly for working-class families, who make up the majority of recorded concealed shoe finds. A pair of shoes could cost around a week’s wages, so they were normally repaired, reused and passed between people until they could no longer be worn. A shoe suitable for concealment was therefore often one that had already reached the end of its useful life.

Another theory is that shoes were deliberately chosen because they retained something of their owner’s physical presence. The leather had moulded around the wearer’s foot, creating a kind of impression of them. If the purpose of hiding the shoe was to protect a house from evil spirits, perhaps a heavily worn shoe was thought to be more effective because it carried a stronger connection to its owner.

There is also the question of why this particular find is a pair. There are several theories, but no definite answer. If the smell of leather was believed to repel spirits, perhaps one shoe was intended to be burnt in the fire. Alternatively, given the value of footwear, perhaps one shoe was passed to another family member or friend so that they could benefit from the same protection. We simply do not know.

By the 20th century, deliberately concealing shoes seems to have been a dying practice. Around ten times fewer 20th-century finds have been recorded than those from the 19th century. If concealing shoes had remained widespread, we might also expect to find more contemporary accounts explaining why people were doing it. Instead, the evidence becomes increasingly scarce. That does not necessarily mean that everyone who continued the practice fully understood its origins. One account collected in the 1930s describes how an informant’s grandmother placed one shoe from a pair beneath the floorboards when the family moved house in London, apparently to make sure they settled into their new home.

There are also examples from the 20th century where shoes seem to have been concealed for more sentimental or commemorative reasons rather than as protection. When a new shoe factory opened in Norwich in 1964, for example, one of the company’s boots was placed in its foundations when the building was completed.

Could something similar have happened at Milwards? We cannot say for certain, but it raises an interesting possibility: perhaps by the 20th century, the practice had changed from a protective ritual into something more symbolic - a way of marking a new building, a new beginning, or the history of the people who made it.